Nestled in the heart of Naples, NY, Middletown Tavern presents a menu that masterfully blends comfort food with gourmet touches. The offerings reflect a dedication to fresh ingredients, bold flavors, and a balance between classic American fare and creative culinary twists.
The Tavern Burger is a standout, featuring a juicy, hand-formed beef patty cooked to perfection, topped with aged cheddar, crisp bacon, and a house-made aioli that adds a rich depth of flavor. Those craving something heartier will appreciate the Braised Short Rib, slow-cooked until fork-tender and served with buttery mashed potatoes and a red wine reduction that brings out its deep, savory notes.
Seafood lovers won’t be disappointed with the Blackened Salmon, perfectly seared to create a crisp crust while keeping the inside moist and flaky. It pairs beautifully with the chef’s citrus-infused quinoa and roasted seasonal vegetables. For a more casual yet equally satisfying option, the Beer-Battered Fish & Chips delivers a crispy, golden-brown crunch with a side of house-made tartar sauce and hand-cut fries.
The tavern also excels in its appetizers. The Buffalo Cauliflower Bites offer a spicy, tangy kick that even non-vegetarians will find irresistible, while the Crab-Stuffed Mushrooms bring a creamy, indulgent bite packed with fresh seafood flavors.
No meal here is complete without dessert. The Bourbon Pecan Pie is a must-try, featuring a perfect balance of caramelized nuts and a rich bourbon-infused filling, served warm with a scoop of vanilla bean ice cream. Another highlight is the Chocolate Lava Cake, a decadent treat that oozes with molten chocolate at the first bite, making it an ideal finale to any meal.
With a menu that carefully balances traditional flavors with inventive touches, Middletown Tavern offers something for every palate, ensuring that each dish delivers both familiarity and surprise in the best possible way.